Minnesota Truck Wash: Boiler Scale Broken, 216% ROI

Home 9 Case Studies and Results 9 Minnesota Truck Wash: Boiler Scale Broken, 216% ROI
Key results
8% heat transfer improvement
24°F stack temperature drop
5.8 month payback

Case Study from HydroFLOW USA

Truck wash boiler scale broken and purged

Truck wash boiler scale was coating the internal tubes of a Minnesota truck wash’s 60 HP low-pressure natural gas steam boiler, despite softening and chemical treatment already being in place. Heat transfer was reduced and acid cleaning was being considered. In August 2013 one HydroFLOW® i45 was installed on the feed water line entering the boiler, with the existing treatment left running during a six-month evaluation. The scale became brittle, broke away and purged through blowdown, new scale did not form, and heat transfer efficiency recovered. The evaluation returned a 216% ROI, and acid cleaning was avoided.

The Challenge

  • Truck wash boiler scale persisted despite softening and chemicals
  • Heavy scale coated the internal boiler tubes
  • Heat transfer efficiency was reduced by scale
  • Acid cleaning was being considered
  • The existing treatment had to stay in place during the evaluation

Steam boiler tubes before and after scale removal, Minnesota, USA

The Solution

  • Unit installed: HydroFLOW® i45
  • Installation point: feed water line entering the boiler
  • System: 60 HP low-pressure natural gas steam boiler
  • Installed: August 2013
  • Trial: six months, with softening and chemical treatment left running

The i45 went on the feed line in under an hour, and the softener and chemicals stayed on. The signal makes existing scale brittle so it breaks away and purges through blowdown, while new scale does not form. The boiler technician tracked truck wash boiler scale coming out through blowdown over the six months rather than opening the boiler.

Key Outcomes

R

Stack temperature down from 296°F to 272°F

R

Cash flow payback in under six months

R

Existing scale became brittle and broke away

R

Projected long-term savings above $482,000

Independent Verification

All results in this study were measured and verified by third-party facilities managers and technical staff.

Summary

The evaluation returned a 216% ROI over six months, with the existing scale purged, no new scale formed and acid cleaning avoided. Because the existing softener and chemicals stayed on throughout, the result is what the i45 added on top of them. For anyone running a steam boiler on softened water that still scales, that is the comparison that matters.

Ready to see more?

Ready to explore sustainable water treatment?

Get in touch to find out how HydroFLOW® can work for you.

© 2026 Hydropath Technology Ltd. All rights reserved